Originally Posted by BlueAngel
Stating a negative about a JEW is not anti-semitic.
If you state a negative about me, should I consider that it's anti-Caucasian?
However, I do agree that cbluemagica appears to display intolerance towards those who are different than himself.
The distinction lies in whether it was used in the singular or plural. If the comment was singularly referring to on Jew, that's just ad hominem. If it is referring to Jews as a whole, that's clearly an anti-Semitic generalization. So no, if the statement really was just referring to one person, its not anti-semitic.